Coming Soon: add source block to METADATA.pb

- Repo: librefonts/comingsoon
- Commit: 27c88659
- Config: none
- Status: missing_config
- Confidence: MEDIUM

diff --git a/apache/comingsoon/METADATA.pb b/apache/comingsoon/METADATA.pb
index 8180d1a2dac74805298b3869652a7a0ea479cdb6..b3883b95fbd3796287c31dce6935e0247a50c868 100644 (file)
--- a/apache/comingsoon/METADATA.pb
+++ b/apache/comingsoon/METADATA.pb
@@ -14,3 +14,7 @@ fonts {
 }
 subsets: "latin"
 subsets: "menu"
+source {
+  repository_url: "https://github.com/librefonts/comingsoon"
+  commit: "27c886594addb8deb44976ee37f829f2c8253a9d"
+}

diff --git a/apache/comingsoon/upstream_info.md b/apache/comingsoon/upstream_info.md
new file mode 100644 (file)
index 0000000..0cdcac8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/apache/comingsoon/upstream_info.md
@@ -0,0 +1,79 @@
+# Investigation Report: Coming Soon
+
+## Summary
+
+Coming Soon is a handwriting font designed by Open Window, added to Google Fonts on 2011-01-06. The upstream repository is `librefonts/comingsoon` on GitHub, which contains only TTX-decomposed source files -- no `.glyphs`, `.ufo`, or `.designspace` sources. The repository has a single commit and no `config.yaml`. Since the sources are TTX-only (not gftools-builder compatible), no config.yaml can be created.
+
+## Key Findings
+
+| Field               | Value                                                    |
+|---------------------|----------------------------------------------------------|
+| Family Name         | Coming Soon                                              |
+| Designer            | Open Window                                              |
+| License             | Apache 2.0                                               |
+| Date Added          | 2011-01-06                                               |
+| Repository URL      | https://github.com/librefonts/comingsoon                 |
+| Commit Hash         | 27c886594addb8deb44976ee37f829f2c8253a9d                 |
+| Config YAML         | None (TTX-only sources, not gftools-builder compatible)  |
+| Status              | **no_config_possible**                                   |
+| Confidence          | HIGH                                                     |
+
+## Investigation Details
+
+### METADATA.pb Analysis
+
+The current METADATA.pb at `apache/comingsoon/METADATA.pb` has no `source { }` block. It lists a single font file `ComingSoon-Regular.ttf` at weight 400, normal style.
+
+### Git History in google/fonts
+
+The binary TTF file has two modification commits:
+
+1. **0fc4c4f4a** (2017-12-14) - `apache/comingsoon: contour issues fixed. v1.002 added.` by Micah Stupak. This is the most recent change to the binary, fixing contour issues and bumping to v1.002. This commit was made directly in google/fonts (not via a PR).
+
+2. **58e6b4444** (2017-08-07) - `hotfix-comingsoon: v1.001 added (#768)` by Marc Foley. This renamed the file from `ComingSoon.ttf` to `ComingSoon-Regular.ttf` and updated METADATA.pb. PR #768 had an empty body.
+
+Before that, the font was present since the initial commit `90abd17b4` (2015-03-07) by Dave Crossland.
+
+### Upstream Repository Analysis
+
+The repository at `https://github.com/librefonts/comingsoon` is accessible (not archived). It was created on 2014-07-16 and contains a single commit:
+
+- **27c8865** (2014-10-17) - `update .travis.yml`
+
+The repo contains:
+- Root: TTX-decomposed font files (`ComingSoon.ttf.*.ttx`), a master TTX file (`ComingSoon.ttf.ttx`), `COPYRIGHT.txt`, `DESCRIPTION.en_us.html`, `LICENSE.txt`, `METADATA.json`, `.travis.yml`
+- `src/`: TTX-decomposed sources (`ComingSoon-TTX.ttf.*.ttx`), including TSI tables for VTT hints, plus `METADATA_comments.txt` and `VERSIONS.txt`
+
+The `VERSIONS.txt` shows `ComingSoon.ttf: Version 1.000`. The `METADATA_comments.txt` is essentially empty (just `# COMMENTS`).
+
+There are **no** `.glyphs`, `.ufo`, `.designspace`, or `.sfd` source files anywhere in the repository. The only "source" is the TTX decomposition of the original binary font. This is a legacy librefonts repo created as an automated dump of the Google Fonts font for CI testing purposes, not a true source repository.
+
+### Source File Assessment
+
+The sources are TTX-only. TTX files are XML decompositions of compiled font binaries -- they are not editable design sources and cannot be used with gftools-builder. No `config.yaml` can be created for this repository because gftools-builder requires `.glyphs`, `.ufo`, or `.designspace` sources.
+
+### Binary Modification Note
+
+The current binary in google/fonts (v1.002) was modified directly by Micah Stupak to fix contour issues. This modification was not reflected in the upstream librefonts repo, which still contains the original v1.000 TTX decomposition. The upstream repo predates both hotfixes and does not represent the current state of the font in google/fonts.
+
+### Hotfix Context
+
+PR #768 by Marc Foley (2017-08-07) applied filename normalization (adding `-Regular` suffix). A subsequent direct commit by Micah Stupak (2017-12-14) fixed contour issues and bumped the version to 1.002. Both modifications were done directly in google/fonts.
+
+## Conclusion
+
+The `librefonts/comingsoon` repository is a legacy automated TTX dump, not a true design source repository. It has only one commit. The current binary in google/fonts (v1.002) has been modified beyond what the upstream repo contains (v1.000). Since the repo contains only TTX-decomposed files and no gftools-builder compatible sources, no `config.yaml` is possible.
+
+### Recommended METADATA.pb Source Block
+
+```
+source {
+  repository_url: "https://github.com/librefonts/comingsoon"
+  commit: "27c886594addb8deb44976ee37f829f2c8253a9d"
+}
+```
+
+Note: `config_yaml` is omitted because the repository contains only TTX sources that are not compatible with gftools-builder. The upstream repo at this commit contains v1.000 sources, while google/fonts has v1.002 (contour-fixed binary modified directly in google/fonts).
+
+### Status: `no_config_possible`
+### Confidence: HIGH