ad-initial-verified-cas logic broken

In the initial pkinit implementation, the server plugin generates an
incorrect encoding for ad-initial-verified-cas.  In particular, it
assumes that ad-if-relevant takes a single authorization data element
not a sequence of authorization data elements.  Nothing looked at the
authorization data in 1.6.3 so this was not noticed.  However in 1.7,
the FAST implementation looks for authorization data.  In 1.8 several
more parts of the KDC examine authorization data.  The net result is
that the KDC fails to process the TGT it issues.

However on top of this bug, there is a spec problem.  For many of its intended uses, ad-initial-verified-cas needs to be integrity protected by the KDC in order to prevent a client from injecting it.  So, it should be contained in kdc-issued not ad-if-relevant.

For now we're simply removing the generation of this AD element until the spec is clarified.

ticket: 6587
status: open

git-svn-id: svn://anonsvn.mit.edu/krb5/branches/anonymous@23492 dc483132-0cff-0310-8789-dd5450dbe970

diff --git a/src/plugins/preauth/pkinit/pkinit_srv.c b/src/plugins/preauth/pkinit/pkinit_srv.c
index b6cdbb90f58dd616ecbb06707b0fbc6ef0b1aeb5..fcd3e78699e45f1c380de482c6339d67e6a46f1a 100644 (file)
--- a/src/plugins/preauth/pkinit/pkinit_srv.c
+++ b/src/plugins/preauth/pkinit/pkinit_srv.c
@@ -536,64 +536,11 @@ pkinit_server_verify_padata(krb5_context context,
 
     /* return authorization data to be included in the ticket */
     switch ((int)data->pa_type) {
-    case KRB5_PADATA_PK_AS_REQ:
-        my_authz_data = malloc(2 * sizeof(*my_authz_data));
-        if (my_authz_data == NULL) {
-            retval = ENOMEM;
-            pkiDebug("Couldn't allocate krb5_authdata ptr array\n");
-            goto cleanup;
-        }
-        my_authz_data[1] = NULL;
-        my_authz_data[0] = malloc(sizeof(krb5_authdata));
-        if (my_authz_data[0] == NULL) {
-            retval = ENOMEM;
-            pkiDebug("Couldn't allocate krb5_authdata\n");
-            free(my_authz_data);
-            goto cleanup;
-        }
-        /* AD-INITIAL-VERIFIED-CAS must be wrapped in AD-IF-RELEVANT */
-        my_authz_data[0]->magic = KV5M_AUTHDATA;
-        my_authz_data[0]->ad_type = KRB5_AUTHDATA_IF_RELEVANT;
-
-        /* create an internal AD-INITIAL-VERIFIED-CAS data */
-        pkinit_authz_data = malloc(sizeof(krb5_authdata));
-        if (pkinit_authz_data == NULL) {
-            retval = ENOMEM;
-            pkiDebug("Couldn't allocate krb5_authdata\n");
-            free(my_authz_data[0]);
-            free(my_authz_data);
-            goto cleanup;
-        }
-        pkinit_authz_data->ad_type = KRB5_AUTHDATA_INITIAL_VERIFIED_CAS;
-        /* content of this ad-type contains the certification
-           path with which the client certificate was validated
-        */
-        pkinit_authz_data->contents = krb5_authz.data;
-        pkinit_authz_data->length = krb5_authz.length;
-        retval = k5int_encode_krb5_authdata_elt(pkinit_authz_data,
-                                                &encoded_pkinit_authz_data);
-#ifdef DEBUG_ASN1
-        print_buffer_bin((unsigned char *)encoded_pkinit_authz_data->data,
-                         encoded_pkinit_authz_data->length,
-                         "/tmp/kdc_pkinit_authz_data");
-#endif
-        free(pkinit_authz_data);
-        if (retval) {
-            pkiDebug("k5int_encode_krb5_authdata_elt failed\n");
-            free(my_authz_data[0]);
-            free(my_authz_data);
-            goto cleanup;
-        }
-
-        my_authz_data[0]->contents =
-            (krb5_octet *) encoded_pkinit_authz_data->data;
-        my_authz_data[0]->length = encoded_pkinit_authz_data->length;
-        *authz_data = my_authz_data;
-        pkiDebug("Returning %d bytes of authorization data\n",
-                 krb5_authz.length);
-        encoded_pkinit_authz_data->data = NULL; /* Don't free during cleanup*/
-        free(encoded_pkinit_authz_data);
-        break;
+/*
+ * This code used to generate ad-initial-verified-cas authorization data.
+ * However that has been removed until the ad-kdc-issued discussion can happen
+ * in the working group.  Dec 2009
+ */
     default:
         *authz_data = NULL;
     }