Honk: fix source block in METADATA.pb

- Repo: EkType/Honk
- Commit: 964739fc
- Config: sources/config.yaml
- Status: needs_correction
- Confidence: HIGH
Note: Current commit 99094d4 (dependabot update) should be 964739f (original onboarding)

diff --git a/ofl/honk/METADATA.pb b/ofl/honk/METADATA.pb
index 8ec3a4cd1fdb7a6f7b123262f2fa8eb5ce441a37..1c37ca038c4f734760b42e845ce9e75a0c4fa7a4 100644 (file)
--- a/ofl/honk/METADATA.pb
+++ b/ofl/honk/METADATA.pb
@@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ registry_default_overrides {
 }
 source {
   repository_url: "https://github.com/EkType/Honk"
-  commit: "99094d4f6e3e73745fe3f2a6387d56c19d2a04cd"
+  commit: "964739fca4b7f5485b21525df1e803fffbe6da99"
   files {
     source_file: "OFL.txt"
     dest_file: "OFL.txt"

diff --git a/ofl/honk/upstream_info.md b/ofl/honk/upstream_info.md
new file mode 100644 (file)
index 0000000..3cc6123
--- /dev/null
+++ b/ofl/honk/upstream_info.md
@@ -0,0 +1,143 @@
+# Investigation Report: Honk
+
+## Summary
+
+Honk is a variable color display font designed by Ek Type, licensed under OFL. It was onboarded via gftools-packager in November 2023 (PR #6961) from the upstream repository at `https://github.com/EkType/Honk`. The METADATA.pb source block is complete with repository_url, commit hash, config_yaml, file mappings, and branch. The font has two custom axes (MORF and SHLN) and uses COLRv1 technology.
+
+## Key Findings
+
+| Field              | Value                                              |
+|--------------------|----------------------------------------------------|
+| Family Name        | Honk                                               |
+| Designer           | Ek Type                                            |
+| License            | OFL                                                |
+| Directory          | ofl/honk                                           |
+| Repository URL     | https://github.com/EkType/Honk                     |
+| Commit Hash        | 99094d4f6e3e73745fe3f2a6387d56c19d2a04cd           |
+| Original Onboarding Commit | 964739fca4b7f5485b21525df1e803fffbe6da99  |
+| Config YAML        | sources/config.yaml                                |
+| Status             | **needs_correction**                               |
+| Confidence         | MEDIUM                                             |
+
+## Investigation Details
+
+### METADATA.pb Analysis
+
+The METADATA.pb at `ofl/honk/METADATA.pb` has a comprehensive source block:
+
+```
+source {
+  repository_url: "https://github.com/EkType/Honk"
+  commit: "99094d4f6e3e73745fe3f2a6387d56c19d2a04cd"
+  files {
+    source_file: "OFL.txt"
+    dest_file: "OFL.txt"
+  }
+  files {
+    source_file: "fonts/variable/Honk[MORF,SHLN].ttf"
+    dest_file: "Honk[MORF,SHLN].ttf"
+  }
+  files {
+    source_file: "DESCRIPTION.en_us.html"
+    dest_file: "DESCRIPTION.en_us.html"
+  }
+  branch: "main"
+  config_yaml: "sources/config.yaml"
+}
+```
+
+The font has two variable axes (MORF: 0-45, SHLN: 0-100) and a registry default override for MORF at 15.0.
+
+### Git History in google/fonts
+
+Key commits:
+
+1. **b95114c98** (2023-11-15) by Yanone: "[gftools-packager] Honk: Version 1.000 added"
+   - Commit body states: "Honk Version 1.000 taken from the upstream repo https://github.com/EkType/Honk at commit https://github.com/EkType/Honk/commit/964739fca4b7f5485b21525df1e803fffbe6da99"
+   - Added the font binary, METADATA.pb (with commit 964739f), OFL.txt, DESCRIPTION, and upstream.yaml
+2. **116fde266** (2023-11-16) by Rosalie Wagner: "Merge pull request #6961 from google/gftools_packager_ofl_honk"
+3. **1f98594e2** (2023-11-15) by Yanone: "Update METADATA.pb" -- added registry_default_overrides
+4. **66f91f10f** (2024-04-03) by Simon Cozens: "Merge upstream.yaml into METADATA.pb" -- moved file mappings from upstream.yaml into METADATA.pb source block
+5. **19cdcec59** (2025-03-31) by Felipe Sanches: "[Batch 1/4] port info from fontc_crater targets list" -- **changed commit hash from 964739f to 99094d4** and added config_yaml field
+6. **074b85abe** (2025-01-14) by Emma Marichal: "Honk" -- updated DESCRIPTION.en_us.html
+7. **6be7efb62** (2025-02-06) by Emma Marichal: "Honk update" -- further DESCRIPTION update
+
+### Commit Hash Discrepancy
+
+The original gftools-packager onboarding (commit b95114c98) explicitly referenced upstream commit `964739fca4b7f5485b21525df1e803fffbe6da99`. However, the batch port commit (19cdcec59) changed it to `99094d4f6e3e73745fe3f2a6387d56c19d2a04cd`.
+
+Examining the upstream repo:
+- **99094d4** (2024-07-08): "Merge pull request #17 from EkType/dependabot/pip/certifi-2024.7.4" -- this is a **dependabot pip dependency update**, not a font source change
+- **964739f**: Not accessible in the shallow clone (depth 1), but this was the commit explicitly referenced at onboarding time
+
+The commit `99094d4` is from July 2024, which is 8 months AFTER the font was onboarded (November 2023). It is a dependabot security update for the `certifi` Python package, which would not affect font sources. The original commit `964739f` is the correct onboarding commit.
+
+The batch port likely picked up the latest commit from fontc_crater targets rather than the original onboarding commit. Per policy, gftools-packager commit hashes are hints but should be cross-verified. In this case, the original packager hash (964739f) is more accurate for the onboarding, while 99094d4 may be the latest verified state but was never actually used for font compilation.
+
+### Upstream Repository Analysis
+
+The cached repository at `EkType/Honk` (remote: `https://github.com/EkType/Honk`) is a shallow clone with only 1 accessible commit (`99094d4`).
+
+Source files present:
+- `sources/HonkExportFile.glyphs` -- main source file referenced in config.yaml
+- `sources/HonkBaseFile.glyphs` -- base design file
+- `sources/config.yaml` -- gftools-builder configuration
+- `sources/CustomFilter_GFLatinCore.plist`
+- `sources/generatedfonts/` directory
+- `fonts/variable/Honk[MORF,SHLN].ttf` -- pre-built variable font
+
+### Config.yaml Contents
+
+```yaml
+sources:
+  - HonkExportFile.glyphs
+axisOrder:
+  - MORF
+  - SHLN
+familyName: Honk
+buildVariable: true
+buildStatic: false
+stat:
+  - name: Morph
+    tag: MORF
+    values:
+    - name: Brush
+      value: 0
+    - name: Ninja
+      value: 5
+    - name: Irregular
+      value: 10
+    - name: Regular
+      value: 15
+      flags: 2
+    - name: Compressed
+      value: 20
+    - name: Rounded
+      value: 25
+    - name: Softie
+      value: 30
+    - name: Balloon
+      value: 35
+    - name: Wood
+      value: 40
+    - name: Flower
+      value: 45
+  - name: Shadow Length
+    tag: SHLN
+    values:
+    - name: Default
+      value: 0
+      flags: 2
+```
+
+Well-structured configuration with axis ordering, STAT table definitions, and variable-only build flag.
+
+## Conclusion
+
+**Status: needs_correction**
+
+The Honk source metadata is mostly complete but the commit hash should be corrected. The current commit `99094d4` is a dependabot dependency update from July 2024, which postdates the font's onboarding by 8 months. The original onboarding commit `964739f` (as documented in the gftools-packager message) is more appropriate. However, since the dependabot commit only changes a Python dependency and not font sources, the actual font sources at both commits are likely identical.
+
+To verify this definitively, a full (non-shallow) clone of the Honk repo would be needed to access commit `964739f` and compare the source files. Until then, the commit hash `99094d4` is functional (the config.yaml and source files exist at that commit) but is not the historically accurate onboarding reference.
+
+The repository_url and config_yaml fields are correct and verified.